Friday, 19 May 2017
Full Time For Part Time
National League side Aldershot are now offering 52 week contracts to players in a bid stop them being poached by other sides. They say the move is a 'calculated risk' in adding a further eight weeks of pay to the existing 44 week schedule that National League sides usually offer.
With the administrative 'season' ending on June 30th, usually National League sides would sign players from July 1st through to the end of the playing season in early May, but the Shots will now go through to June 30th to match deals offered in the Football League.
The move is a further step towards the National League ending being a part time competition. Chester boss Jon McCarthy says that only his side may be part time next season:
“Next season, you could argue that there will only be Chester that are part time. I know you have the likes of a Dover that will stay part time, but in terms of finances and the way that they work things they are very much full time.
“I think it could be that next season is the last ever season where there is a part time element to the National League. It is turning into the old Fourth Division, which I did play in, and this is League Two standard."
Wednesday, 10 May 2017
Trouble Up North
A trio of National North sides are undergoing ownership issues.
Telford's second attempt at selling shares in the club has been 'disappointing' according to the club.
Just £17,700 of additional shares were purchased in the second window, and no major investor stepped forward following the abolition of ownership limits. Around 65% of the shares still remain unsold and, although technically not currently on sale, the club's Board will consider approaches.
The Board itself has advertised for reinforcements, in a week that has seen club General Manager Sharon Bowyer step down from her role due to family commitments after beginning work for the club when it was reformed.
The Shropshire side say the lack of share sales won't affect next season's budget.
Meanwhile newly relegated Southport have announced a six figure investment from an accountant and a financial advisor, both businessmen in the town. The investment comes as a second businessman claims his offer for the club was totally ignored, while the club's Board went through an unpleasant series of appointments and departures.
Former manager Liam Watson was only recently appointed to the Board but saw his appointment, and that of two others, thrown out due to limitations on the size of the Board in the club's constitution. Watson was subsequently made redundant, with current manager Andy Preece told to re-apply for his job.
Long serving chairman Charlie Clapham will step down from the club, having been a polarising figure among supporters.
Elsewhere, a surprising figure is riding to Darlington's aid.
Raj Singh, previously the chairman and owner of the liquidated Darlington club, has offered £40,000 towards next season's budget in exchange for shares in the club. The move, announced yesterday, will have to go to a vote of shareholders and has already met significant opposition due to Singh's involvement in the collapse five years ago.
A fourth National North side, newly relegated York City, have also released financial results for their final season in the Football League which report a £300,000 loss. A further similar loss is expected for the 16/17 season despite them falling straight through the fifth tier, and the club continues to rely on owner Jason McGill.
McGill's firm, JM Packaging, is now owed over £4,7million, repayable when the club's long delayed move to a new stadium - that remain in planning hell - is finally completed.
Saturday, 6 May 2017
A Rare Glimpse Of Real Life
In a week when the EFL deliberately and willfully agreed to lie to supporters it has finally admitted what has been blatantly obvious for some time.
The EFL says it made a 'difficult decision' in allowing supporters to be lied to about the abandonment of a match, between Leyton Orient and Colchester, but admitted that it was powerless to stop rogue owners. Their own statement notes 'the decision was taken by the EFL to announce the abandonment of the game to clear the pitch and when it was safe, allow the players to return to complete the fixture.'
The statement also states that the EFL wants to protect the legitimacy of the competition which, in a season when teams have been fined for fielding reserve sides against Academy sides from higher grade teams (effectively a third string XI), and now sees honest paying customers fail to watch the match they forked out money to see, legitimate is no longer a word that can be used to describe the EFL.
The only decent thing the EFL have done is acknowledge what everyone knew. That their limited rules on owners were unenforceable and they were powerless to prevent rogue club owners. All the stern words, the threats, and the false hopes over the past years amounted to not one iota of real action. It was nothing more than the illusion of power.
Since their rebranding from the Football League last summer, the EFL has been massively devalued in terms of the integrity that it wishes to protect. Chief Executive Shaun Harvey has repeatedly enraged supporters, who he appears to care little about, with a series of ridiculous ideas that has seen the Checkatrade Trophy turn into the Mickey Mouse cup that many fans jokingly referred to it as - even going as far as bending the rules of the competition to suit the bigger sides.
The actions at Brisbane Road last Saturday should have the FA demand answers from the EFL and Harvey as to why the lifeblood of the game was treated with such utter contempt.
But, in a world of inaction, I won't be holding my breath.
Friday, 5 May 2017
Pomp And Circumstance
A lengthy document was sent out by the Portsmouth Supporters Trust in the past week detailing the club's current predicament and the offer from Michael Eisner and his Tornante vehicle. The document lists a number of things, but a subsequent club statement spelled out the stark message -
Fratton Park is falling down.
Compliance to keep Fratton Park up to capacity in line with the 'Green Guide' - the bible of operating a sports stadium - will cost the club £5million in the coming five years. The club say they have £900,000 of shareholder funds left and no prospect of funding the other work without dipping into the playing budget, meaning sections of the stadium would have to close.
Their story is a familiar one. "Recommended" works that were neglected in previous years by failing owners now became urgent and the funding required quickly added up. Instead of doing one years work in one year, you have ten years work to do in five.
A stadium that is the biggest asset of most clubs suddenly becomes the biggest liability also.
Portsmouth can ill afford to reduce capacity from the current 18,931. Average attendance this season is 16,771 - a lower end Championship average - and Saturday's final match against Cheltenham sold out nearly a month ago. The club has less than 10% of its capacity spare each game with the largest attendance just 300 under capacity.
With the news of the cash shortage, Eisner addressed supporters last night to lay out his proposal. Shareholders would effectively get their money back, the Trust would be removed from the Board in favour of a 'heritage' option, Eisner would put in an additional £10million, and the offer was take-it or leave-it.
The Supporters Trust then offered an alternative funding method, asking 8,000 supporters to put in £15 a month - over £500 each over three years - to fund repair works. The Trust has not recommended an option, leaving it to the individual supporter to make up their mind.
The Pompey Supporters have a difficult decision but a Championship level club without a millionaire or billionaire backer is not going to compete at that level any more.
Thursday, 4 May 2017
Hanging In The Balance
Hartlepool's 'owner' Gary Coxall has quit the club, and pushed the agenda towards supporter ownership on the eve of their do-or-die last game of the season to secure League survival.
The Monkey Hangers need to win their final match, at home to title contenders Doncaster, and hope Newport fail to beat mid-table Notts County in order to secure their League Two place. They have failed to record a win in the last ten matches, a run that cost manager Dave Jones his job, and have slashed admission prices for Saturday's game to £5 in a bid to pack out the ground.
Quite why a Dubai based recruitment firm owned a Northern football side with a Council owned ground has always been puzzling. JPNG took over less than two years ago with an Ilford, Essex UK base and immediately raised eyebrows. Coxall arrived with a partner, Peter Goldberg, whose disappearance from the scene led to a series of cash crises that led to a pair of winding-up petitions and wages being delayed.
In March this year, a Debenture was registered against the club at Companies House, one of four charges currently secured on the assets of the club including the lease of the ground. The 'borrower' on the debenture is Coxall as Chairman of the club. The 'lender' John Blackledge of Sage Investments Limited. The deal was brokered by Matt Haycox for Access Finance in Leeds. Whether Haycox is the same person listed at Companies House as a disqualified Director is unknown, nor would it prevent him from brokering the deal.
According to Companies House, Sage Investments has a Director who resigned in 2004 called Pamela Jane Duxbury. Coxall has handed the Chairman's role to the club's recently installed Finance Director - Pam Duxbury - apparently working on behalf of Sage, but infers from his statement that he retains ownership of the club.
Quite the extent of the debt to Sage Investments, or the current ownership picture of the club, remains up in the air. Debate rages on what percentages of the club Coxall, Sage, and Goldberg own with little firm evidence
However if Coxall was a poor choice of owner, the other option on the table was even worse. Peter Harris and Stephen Murrall, of "The Monkey Hangers" consortium who attempted a takeover prior to JPNG, are now facing a fraud trial relating to a series of people and HMRC in the run up to their bid failure.
Duxbury has been quick to pursue ownership talks with the Supporters Trust, holding a meeting on the evening of Coxall's announcement, but the Trust say they have no short or long term agenda to own the club.
Failure on Saturday could well see another HUFC plunged into the abyss.
Saturday, 22 April 2017
Darlo Facing Cash Questions
Five years after reforming, Darlington have admitted they are facing a cash crisis and are seeking talks with potential investors.
The club has been told it will not be able to compete in the National North play-offs after failing to meet ground grading requirements. They are one of three clubs barred by the League due to not having 500 seats under cover - a League requirement rather than a FA one - with all three appealing the decision.
However two Darlington Directors have resigned over the issue, and a third is considering his position, citing 'vitriol' from supporters in the wake of the news. The club says that they could not afford the six-figure cost of installing the seating anyway, with losses mounting following their move back to Darlington after an enforced exile in Bishop Auckland, and would struggle to raise the £500,000 needed to achieve the full 'A' grading needed to remain at National Premier level, let alone the financial needs on the pitch.
The supporter owned club has reported debts of £80,000 and has required a £50,000 loan from Directors and outside supporters to stay afloat this season. Operating costs of £35,000 over budget this season were compounded by income underperforming by £30,000 under the projected figures, with £15,000 of debt still on the books from last season.
Manager Martin Gray has been told to cut his budget by £85,000 for the coming season to balance the books, with the triple promotion winner warning supporters that he will leave if that is the case. Gray says he needs a £400,000 budget to compete at National North level - £10,000 a week on part time deals - with the club finances showing that 70% of income was directed to the playing budget.
Gray says the ownership model has to change to compete at their level and above, telling a supporter forum 'as a fan owned club we have gone as far as we can go. We need a different direction for this football club to go forward. We are an embarrassment, a laughing stock in the football world.'
Gray says he is in talks with investors who are capable of pushing the club forward, but that the supporters will have to accept a minority stake for it to happen.
Thursday, 20 April 2017
Money No Object, Object To No Money
Portsmouth's takeover discussions should lead to a Supporters Trust representative remaining on the Board, according to a survey by the Trust.
The view appears to be at odds to early statements from Michael Eisner, who sees the supporters being part of a 'heritage' board to protect the finer details of the Portsmouth 'brand' rather than the operational running of the club.
More than 2000 supporters largely backed talks with the former Disney chief, and generally thought the club would be able to achieve a higher league placing with a Billionaire behind them than the current ownership setup, although they wanted to retain a supporter voice on the club Board.
However when it came to funding a new stadium and increased investment in the playing budget, supporters voted for new shareholders or owners to be the ones to cover the financial needs, with less than 10% of respondents expecting the current shareholders, including the supporters, to cover the bills.
Nearly half of respondents had 'no reservations' on Eisner buying the club, with an almost equal number not wanting a single person owning the club again.
Meanwhile the single owner model remains badly broken at Leyton Orient. Off-field staff have issued a statement saying they have started a grievance process with the club over unpaid wages, but that the complaint has not been responded to.
Staff still have not received their March wages, with little more than a week until April's sums are due, and have received no communication as to whether they will receive the money either.
Over at National League Barrow, their single owner model has just recorded a £1million debt to their owner over the past trading year. Owner Paul Casson loaned the club £990,754 in the past 12 months to the end of May 2016, with the US based businessman telling the press he had no intention of calling in the debt.
That £1million investment saw the Bluebirds end the 2015/16 season in 9th place, ten points outside the play-offs. This season they are in 7th place, outside the play-offs by four points with just two games remaining.
With a similar debt likely to have been accumulated this season the Bluebirds are likely to be nearly £3million in debt by the time the current financial year is complete, on fairly static average attendances of 1300.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)